Introduction Terminology

Relationships with … … anyone … ⚕︎ doctors

People's desires and focus … caused us to create Care Systems
… until the closing phase of life.

Lessons Learned :  🩸 blood pressure meter, 💊︎▦ pill-organizer-planner-sorter, upright rollator.

Important statistics

Terminology

Activities of Daily Living ADL
Instrumental Activities of Daily Living IADL

Social Determinants of Health SDoH

Activities of Daily Living ADL

  • 🛏🪑 Get in and out of bed or a chair without help. [1]
  • 🚻︎ 🚽︎ Use the toilet by yourself.
  • 🛀︎🚿︎  Take a bath or shower without help. [1]
  • 🪒🪮🪥 Shave, comb your hair, and brush your teeth on your own.
  • 👕︎  Dress and undress without help. [1]
  • 🍽  Feed yourself without help.

Seems to not include 🚼︎ babies nor toddlers.

Social Determinants of Health SDoH

  1. 📈︎ Economic stability:
        income (including eliminating poverty ),
        job opportunities,
        job security and working life conditions.

  2. 🏛 Education:
        access, affordable, of decent quality,
        early childhood development,
        language and literacy skills.

  3. Healthcare:
        access, affordable, of decent quality.

  4. Neighborhood and Built Environment:
        safe housing, transportation and neighborhoods;
        ~polluted air, water, soil and housing;
        access to nutritious foods (~ food insecurity);  and
        access to physical activity opportunities.

  5. Social protection and community context:
        social inclusion, non-discrimination (~ racism, violence, structural conflict). [2] [3] [4]

… ⚕︎ doctors

Relationships between ⚕︎ doctors and patients follow one of several models:

  1. Doctor Paternalistic (Priestly / Parental / Commander / Doctor-Knows-Best) model:
        The original model.
        Makes decisions for the patient.
        Tells patient only what they need to know.
        Works well only for unconscious patients with no family member available, and for vulnerable patients — frail, poor, elderly, and anyone who tends to do what they are told.
        For reasonably-intelligent, reasonably-educated, reasonably-connected patients, we eventually invented …

  2. Doctor Informative (Scientific / Engineering / Technician / Consumer) model:
        The doctor tells the patient facts and figures;  the patient decides everything.
        Can work well if (A) choices are clear, (B) tradeoffs are straightforward, and (C) the patient is informed and has clear preferences.
        But patients want more than information and control — we also want guidance.  So we eventually invented …

  3. Doctor Interpretive (Shared-Decision-Making / Counselor / Contractor) model:
        Ask:
            "What is most important to you?" and
            "What are your worries?"
        Then:
            tell patient what you know, and
            guide them as to which options will best reach their goals.

    To do this, if you are position of expertise, and need someone to talk about an uncomfortable (but important) topic:
        Say "I am worried."
            Pause.  Pause.  Then say what you are worried about.
      •  Ask.  Tell.  Ask.
            Ask the patient "What do you want to know?"
            Tell the other what you know of the subject.
            Ask the patient "What is your understanding of that?"
        What are your biggest fears and concerns?
        What goals are most important to you?
        What tradeoffs are you willing to make?
        What tradeoffs are you not willing to make?

Plus, expanding on Dr Gawande's discussion, with the info in Four Models of the Physician-Patient Relationship  Adobe Acrobat Reader file and The Four Models of the Physician-Patient Relationship.

  1. Doctor Deliberative (Collegial / Teacher / Friend) model:  [TODO:  Fill this in.]

And in table format: Table 1.  ⚕︎ Doctor Models. Doctor Model > Doctor Paternalistic
Priestly / Parental / Commander / Doctor-Knows-Best Doctor Informative
Scientific / Engineering Doctor Interpretive
Shared-Decision-Making / Counselor / Contractor Doctor Deliberative
Collegial / Teacher / Friend Physician's role GuardianTechnical expertCounselor or adviserFriend or teacher Physician's obligation Promote what the doctor believes is in the patient's best-interest, regardless of what the patient wants at the time Provide relevant factual information to the patient, and implement patient's course of action Elucidate relevant patient values, interpret for this siltation, inform patient as needed, and implement patient's course of action Persuade patient of admirable healthcare values, work with the patient to determine a course of action, and implement it. Works well for patients who … Are unconscious, with an ⚠︎ unplanned medical emergency.
Are meek, frail, or elderly patients, who tend to do what they are told. Can make a decision, or consent to a choice made by their doctor Has, or can develop, a real understanding of themselves, and information provided Has, or can develop, a real understanding of themselves, and information provided Concept of patient's autonomy Agrees with objectively-determined values.  May be given choice of yes-no or accept-reject. Controls their own medical care, via making their own choices.  May be given choice of _____. Understands what they want in the medical care.  Has wide choice of treatment options, which might be accepted, rejected, or trailered. Moral self-development relevant to medical care Patient's values Objective, and shared by physician and patient Defined, fixed, and known to the patient Inchoate and conflicting, requiring elucidation Open to development and revision, through moral discussion

Questions may come from fear — answer them.

The job of ⚕︎ doctors is to enable wellbeing.  Wellbeing is about whatever reasons that person wishes to be alive, at whatever stage of life that person happens to be, at that time.

… caused us to create Care Systems

Image of Where Should You Be Treated: When to Visit Your Doctor, Urgent Care, Emergency. Select to view larger.

Standard medical care treatment priority:

  • Extend life.
  • Sacrifice the quality of your existence now (e.g., with surgery, chemotherapy, or ICU ), for the chance of
    gaining 📅︎ good-quality time later.

This seems best for young, healthy, stable people, including those with medical issues that can be fixed.

Hospice treatment priority:

  • Help someone with a fatal illness to have the
    fullest possible life right now.

In terminal illness, that means focusing on:

  • Freedom from pain and discomfort.
    Keep in mind the Peak-End Rule of remembering pain and joy.
  • Maintain mental awareness.
  • Getting out with family as practical.
  • Being happy.

The job of any ⚕︎ doctor [ or 3-Stage Retirement Village 3SRV / CCRC / LPC / LPRC / LTCF  ] is to:

  • Support quality of life:
  • As much freedom from ravages of disease as possible.
  • Retention of enough function for active engagement in the world.

Three Plagues of Nursing Home Existence:

  • Boredom.
  • Loneliness.
  • Helplessness.
Let's try to fix that.  Bring in life:  green plants in every room, garden, animals.

Eating alone is not very stimulating.

The chance to shape one's story is essential to sustaining meaning in life.

For all 💉︎📅︎ 🇺🇸 vaccines applicable to you, make an appointment to protect you against 💥︎🏥︎ severe disease.

Healthy aging, from ISB.

Links to state and national aging organizations.

Good but difficult article on why we age "Selectively advantageous instability in biotic and pre-biotic systems and implications for evolution and aging."  Frontiers in Aging.   . DOI: 10.3389/​fragi.2024.1376060   Accessed .

⚰ All-cause mortality and ⚕︎ long-term health are predicted much more accurately by cardiorespiratory fitness (CRF) than by body-mass index (BMI). [5] DOI: 10.1136/​bjsports-2024-108748

If it applies, review the Dementia Road Map:  A Guide for Family and Care Partners.  Adobe Acrobat Reader file

Lessons Learned

Do not fear the 🩸 blood pressure meter, 💊︎▦ pill-organizer-planner-sorter, upright rollator.

Learn all you can from local sources of health information (our local PBS station has a great local program on that), and academia.

If you are over 65 years old, or care for one, periodically (every 3 years?), check your meds against Beers Criteria,  Adobe Acrobat Reader file and bring any matches to the attention of your care team.

📅︎ Way ahead of time, we should:

  1. Create a good:
        Durable Power of Attorney PoA for Health Care DPoAH;   perhaps via Caring Info > your state, and a healthcare provider > link Download our DPOAH form.  Adobe Acrobat Reader file
        Do Not Resuscitate DNR [ , Do Not Attempt Resuscitation DNAR, Allow Natural Death AND, or 🇬🇧 🇨🇳 🇰🇵 🇰🇷 🇷🇺 🇪🇸 🇺🇦 🇻🇳 POLST.  ]
        Other written advance directives for healthcare based on input from the subject and any advisors and stakeholders (spouse, ⚕︎ doctor, 🚸︎ kids, etc.), and perhaps tailored by jurisdiction.    Links to these and more, for Michigan.
        Maybe the healthcare info in my insurance company's caregiver info > Care Organizer.
        [ Your death plan (if you have one).
        Contact information for your death doula (if you have one). ]

  2. Store:
        at your main 🏥︎ healthcare provider,
        at your most-likely 🏥︎ hospital,
      •  [ on the door of your refrigerator, in a Vial of Life  Adobe Acrobat Reader file (via a form filler > Start), and
        in your magic 2-cm (1-inch) binder or folder, that contains all documents your team might need in your time of need.  ]

  1. Create a good:
        Durable Power of Attorney PoA for Finances DPoAF.
        Document containing all your financial assets, places, account numbers, contact info, purpose, etc.
          For your team, should you become unable to handle all of your own affairs.
          I added passwords to my computers and phones — obfuscated for printed copies and .PDF exports, while visible in the original electronic document.
          Maybe the financial info in my insurance company's caregiver info > Care Organizer.
        Your death plan (if you have one).
        Contact information for your death doula (if you have one).

  2. Store:
        in your magic 2-cm (1-inch) binder or folder, that contains all documents your team might need in your time of need.

  1. Ensure that 👪︎ any relatives likely to be there near the end:
      •  have these documents (both sets),
      •  know where you keep the original master copies,
      •  have read them, and
      •  are mentally prepared to follow through on these wishes.

If you don't know where you're going, any road will take you there.

    — George Harrison.

We are all temporarily-abled.

    — Source unknown, I heard it a long time ago.  Although on , I heard Dr. Siddhartha Mukherjee say that ⚕︎ doctors understand very well that they will soon be on the other side of the exam table.

Design everything for your future self:


⚰ All-cause mortality and ⚕︎ long-term health are predicted much more accurately by cardiorespiratory fitness (CRF) than by body-mass index (BMI). [5] DOI: 10.1136/​bjsports-2024-108748

There are four types of anesthesia:

  • Local      — numbing a small area, such as a dentist numbing a tooth before working on it.
  • Regional — numbing a large area, such as an epidural for the pain of childbirth.
  • Sedation — somewhat-suppressing the central nervous system, while still letting the patient follow verbal instructions, such as for colonoscopies or removal of wisdom teeth.
  • General  — greatly-suppressing central nervous system activity, causing unconsciousness and total lack of sensation, for invasive procedures such as surgery.

If your region has a PACE program, check into it.  Part of Medicaid.  But instead of running a 24/7/365 skilled nursing home, they try to keep you in your home, for as long as practical.  They provide some services at home.  But most services are supplied through a sort of day camp:  one site per country (or so), Monday-Friday 8am-4pm, hang out with your buddies playing cards or whatever, breakfast, lunch and a snack, bathing services???

If you are a caregiver/carer, this could be just the sort of respite care you need to maintain your sanity.  Gotta check into this.  I hear many of their clients are very satisfied, and 95% of clients stay home until they die.  If your area does not have a PACE program …

🇺🇸 In the USA, you can use data from Medicare.gov to find a good ⚕︎ doctor, 🏥︎ hospital, nursing home, rehab, home services, supplies, equipment, etc. > your need > your location > set Sort by to Overall Rating, if possible > look for good overall and patient satisfaction ratings; or 📱︎☎ 1-800-MEDICARE.

🇺🇸 In the USA, you can use data from US News and World Reports to find a good ⚕︎ doctor, 🏥︎ hospital, senior living, Medicare Advantage company, drug, treatment, or diet > your need > your location > set Sort By to Ranking, if possible > scorecard, outcomes, etc.

= Search carefully for 3-Stage Retirement Villages 3SRV / CCRC / LPC / LPRC / LTCF.   TODO:  write this section.

BTW, even if you or your 👪︎ loved-one is in one of these facilities, y'all need to work out who is going to:
    🍳︎🧹🛀︎ cook, clean, bathe, etc.;
    📅︎  🚗︎⚕︎  maintain a calendar, take to doctors appointments, etc.;
  •  🍲︎  💊︎    give food and medications;
  •  🍲︎         maintain a food supply in fridge;
    💊︎▦      set up a pill-organizer-planner-sorter, and keep a steady supply of refills;
    🔊︎👂︎      verify, clean and replace parts in hearing aids;
    💪︎🧠👥︎ see to exercise, brain, and social needs;  and
    handle all the other Instrumental Activities of Daily Living IADL.

Do not fear the 💊︎pill-organizer-planner-sorter

I heard medical professionals call it a 💊︎mediset, but pill-sorter, pill-organizer or pill-planner are more specific, and Search Engines say are more commonly-used.  I prefer pill-sorter.

Regardless, starting to use one too early is way better than starting too late:

Important statistics …

63% of doctors   overestimate future survival time.  By an average of 530%!

17% of doctors underestimate future survival time.

Risk factors for falling (and breaking your hip):

  1. Poor balance.
  2. Taking more than 💊︎💊︎💊︎💊︎ four prescriptions ℞.
  3. Muscle weakness.

  • None of these:  12% (⅛) chance of falling, in a year.
  • All three:   almost 100% chance of falling, in a year.

43% of caregivers/carers are men — about 3:4 men:women — close to gender-parity.  This is not just a women's issue!

Caregivers/carers often die before their care recipient. [citation needed.]

If you have any of these issues — or even if you don't:

Cancer costs are U-shaped:

  • High initial costs.
    [ For example, in the patient's first year with the condition, to get worked up, diagnosed, do patient education, decide upon and start a treatment plan compatible with patient, etc. ]
    [ OK. ]
  • Reasonable maintenance costs.
    If treatment works, costs taper to US$2000 (€1900) / year.
    [ Excellent. ]
  • Final year of life costs average US$94 000 (€88 000) / year.  [ Pre-COVID! ]
    [ May be useless or less-than-useless. ]

25% of Medicare spending is for 5% of patients, in their final year of life.

  • Most of that goes to final few months of life, where it gives little apparent benefit.
    Or negative benefit.

More than half of those living in 3-Stage Retirement Villages 3SRV / CCRC / LPC / LPRC / LTCF run through their savings.

"Visualizing America's Average Retirement Savings, by Age."  The Visual Capitalist.  May 14, 2024.